The “Overqualified” Myth
I’ve never turned down an applicant because I felt he or she was overqualified, and frankly, I don’t think anyone does. We hear this phrase a lot but it likely just falls in one of these categories:
- The hiring manager is afraid the applicant has been around long enough to have some really solid bad habits and doesn’t want to invest the energy to change those.
- The hiring manager is intimidated by the applicant’s qualifications and feels unable to manage him/her.
- The hiring manager doesn’t like the applicant and doesn’t feel she would fit in will as part of the team but could certainly never state that.
- The hiring manager doesn’t really feel the applicant is a good candidate but saying he/she is “overqualified’ is a whole lot easier than stating the opposite.
- The interviewer questions the accuracy of some of the “qualifications” on the resume and is trying to get the applicant to give a more realistic overview.
- The interviewer is afraid the candidate will use his/her degrees as a crutch in place of real workplace skills.
- The interviewer is concerned that the candidate will expect compensation beyond their contribution to the organization.
Sure, I’d prefer to have a Master Gardener consult with me on making my yard a showplace, rather than someone who just has a “green thumb.”
Would you turn a doctor away because she was “overqualified” for your simple sore throat?
Would you send a carpenter away because he had too much experience?
If you’re hearing this phrase a lot in your interviews, look for the real reason you’re not getting opportunities. I am confident it falls in line with one of the bullet points above. There’s no such thing as “overqualified.”
Please register for a free account to view this content
We hope you have enjoyed the 10 discipleship resources you have read in the last 30 days.
You have exceeded your 10 piece content limit.
Create a free account today to keep fueling your spiritual journey!
Already a member? Login to iDisciple